woman holding face in front of open laptop to signify wired but tired

Tired but Wired After 40? Why Food, Fasting, and Sleep Matter for Women

Do you feel more anxious, irritable, exhausted, or overwhelmed as you age? Your nervous system may be playing a role.

Exercise physiologist Dr. Stacy Sims explains that during perimenopause and menopause, women can become more “sympathetically driven.”

What does that mean?

Our sympathetic nervous system activates the fight-or-flight response, increasing alertness and preparing us to meet life’s demands. We need this drive at times for us to “effort,” but it can get overly activated.

As estrogen, testosterone, dhea, and progesterone fluctuate and decline, changes in our autonomic nervous system can affect how we respond to stress. Some women experience greater difficulty moving out of that heightened state of alertness, contributing to disrupted sleep, anxiety, irritability, and difficulty recovering from everyday stressors.

The good news is that there are practical ways to support nervous-system balance, and some begin with changing our relationship with food.

Why Men and Women Respond Differently to Fasting

Much of the traditional research on exercise, metabolism, and fasting has been conducted on men. But as Dr. Sims reminds us, women are not small men. When I first heard this, I felt mad. I have been an athlete for my whole life, focusing on health, nutrition, exercise, and sleep. But the tips I was following were based on male data?????????

Ugh. I wasted so much time. Hopefully, you won’t have to since I’m sharing this information.

Male and female bodies differ in how they use energy, respond to stress, and regulate reproductive hormones. Which means, what works for men might be ineffective or worse: harmful for women!

For example, women generally have a greater proportion of oxidative muscle fibers, which are especially efficient at using fat for energy during endurance activity. Men typically have a greater proportion of glycolytic fibers, which rely more heavily on carbohydrates during intense exercise.

Women also have hormonal systems that can be particularly sensitive to inadequate energy intake. The hypothalamus, a small but powerful region of the brain, monitors energy availability and helps regulate reproduction, appetite, metabolism, and stress. What that means is, you may feel less energy on average than a man if you aren’t fueling your body correctly and sleeping enough.

Men are not immune to the consequences of underfueling, but the responses can differ. So they can get away with more calorie restriction than women. Especially women in perimenopause or beyond.

This is one reason Dr. Sims cautions active women against prolonged fasting, particularly when combined with exercise. Restricting food while placing additional demands on the body can contribute to increased physiological stress and inadequate recovery. If you are an exercise in the morning kind of woman, be sure you have nutrition on board before you do!

And here is another secret: restricting can actually lead to the body holding on to fat. I know! That’s wild, right? Sims and others are clear on this: if you are a woman who is just looking to lose the belly fat or drop a small amount of weight (10 lbs or less), restricting is not good. In fact, it can cause your body to conserve fat.

For years and years I exercise fasted. Up at 5, at the gym at 5:30, then maybe having fuel around 11 or so. Nope. That is not good. I’ve radically changed my approach and I am seeing the results. While everyone differs even with our commonalities with women, I will share that I lost weight when I entered menopause. I follow Dr. Sim’s approach to food and exercise and I work with a Naturopath on getting my hormones in healthy ranges. Not sure what your results will be, but this path is a good one. I see countless women with great results.

Importantly, this doesn’t mean intermittent fasting is harmful to every woman or beneficial to every man. Research suggests that some women, particularly those who are obese, can benefit from carefully designed fasting approaches. But again: if you are in range of your healthy weight, don’t restrict your eating.

The concern is applying the same fasting recommendations to everyone without considering sex, age, activity level, and nutritional needs.

Read more about why Dr. Sims cautions active women against fasting.

Eat With Your Circadian Rhythm, Not Against It

Our bodies operate on approximately 24-hour biological cycles called circadian rhythms. These internal clocks influence everything from sleep and body temperature to cortisol, insulin sensitivity, digestion, and metabolism.

Cortisol naturally rises in the morning to help us wake up and gradually declines throughout the day. Melatonin rises in the evening to prepare us for sleep.

Our metabolism follows daily rhythms too.

For example, research suggests that our bodies generally handle glucose more efficiently earlier in the day than late at night. Eating most of our calories in the evening may work against these natural metabolic patterns.

Johns Hopkins Medicine explains how meal timing influences our circadian rhythms and metabolism.

Dr. Sims recommends “front-loading” our nutrition, meaning eating a substantial breakfast and lunch rather than saving most of our calories for dinner.

This is particularly relevant for women who skip breakfast, drink coffee throughout the morning, exercise without eating, and then consume most of their food late in the day.

Consider these changes:

  • Eat within approximately 30 minutes of waking. If you aren’t hungry, try adding 15 grams of protein powder to your morning coffee, followed by a nutrient-dense breakfast when you’re ready. The 30-minute window is Dr. Sims’ practical recommendation, not a scientifically established deadline. I add a scoop of protein powder to my morning cold brew because I am not super hungry 30-minutes after waking. One caveat: not all protein powders are “clean.” Look at sources like consumer reports or your favorite AI chat bot to access clean sources. About minute30-60 minutes later, I am ready for a bigger breakfast. Skip the big bowl of oatmeal (I know I know I know: but it is supposed to be healthy!), choose protein rich foods, have some fat and fiber, and even some carbs but not a whole load of them.
  • Eat more of your daily calories earlier in the day, including adequate protein, carbohydrates, healthy fats, and fiber. Fiber can be very hard to access throughout the day. I’ve heard recommendations of up to 50g of fiber a day. To help me meet that goal, I sprinkle Holy Basil Seeds on a lot of my food. They are tasteless and pack a powerful 7-10 grams of fiber a Tablespoon. They do get in your teeth: only down side! In my experience, fiber is the toughest to hit your goals so I add this tip in. Chia seeds and flax can help, but they have less fiber.
  • Fuel your workouts. If you exercise first thing in the morning, consume some protein and carbohydrates beforehand rather than exercising on an empty stomach. What does “some” mean? Dr. Sims recommends 15g of protein if you are just lifting, but if you plan to add cardio in then add 30g of carbohydrate to that meal before working out. Be sure to check out her recommendations about eating post-workout. They blew my mind: How to Fuel After a Workout.
  • Finish eating approximately three hours before bedtime. This supports a natural overnight fast of roughly 11 to 13 hours without deliberately skipping daytime meals. This type of fasting is okay, according to Sims, because you are at total rest and it allows your glymphatic system to do it’s job. Repair and recovery!

You can learn more about Dr. Sims’ exercise and nutrition recommendations in my article, 7 Stacy Sims Health Tips for Women.

What Is Low Energy Availability, and Why Does It Matter?

One of Dr. Sims’ most important concerns is low energy availability (LEA).

Low energy availability occurs when the energy remaining after exercise is insufficient to support the body’s essential physiological functions.

In simpler terms, you’re asking your body to do more than you’re fueling it to do. Every day the number one comment I get from women is, “I am soooo tired!”

But it isn’t always obvious why they feel so fatigued. Women may be eating what seems like a healthy diet while unintentionally consuming too little to support their exercise, recovery, and everyday needs. Especially for women 40 plus: we’ve been raised with this calorie restriction concept to stay thin. Dr. Sims points to the data that shows that it isn’t about calories in, calories out. It’s about quality food.

Consider this: 100 calories of candy is not going to impact your body the same as 100 calories of broccoli. So focusing on calories is not effective. We want to shift our focus to quality, low or non-processed foods, timing of eating, and the connection between our energy and food.

Over time, inadequate fueling can contribute to hormonal disruptions, fatigue, impaired recovery, bone loss, decreased exercise performance, and mood changes.

This is where physical and mental health intersect. Inadequate nutrition can affect the body’s stress response and make it harder to feel physically and emotionally well. In short, contributing to that sympathetic driven “wired but tired” feeling state. Or just flat out TIRED!

Explore her discussion of low energy availability and why adequate carbohydrates matter.

Why Sleep Is Essential for Your Brain and Nervous System

Sleep is one of the most powerful tools we have for physical and mental recovery. It supports immune function, metabolism, memory, emotional regulation, and brain health. When I talked to people about their sleep, there is a lot of stress around it. I typically hear, “Laura, I’ve tried everything. I cannot change my sleep.” Later, I found out, well not EVERYTHING. Stay tuned.

Let’s first explore WHY sleep is so important:

Your Brain Has Its Own Waste-Clearance System

Most people are familiar with the lymphatic system, which helps remove excess fluid and cellular waste from tissues throughout the body.

The brain has a related process called the glymphatic system.

This network facilitates the movement of cerebrospinal fluid through and around brain tissue, helping transport metabolic waste, including proteins such as amyloid-beta and tau.

Research suggests that glymphatic activity is enhanced during sleep, particularly during deep, slow-wave sleep.

Unlike the body’s lymphatic system, which continually transports fluid, glymphatic clearance appears to fluctuate considerably with sleep and wakefulness. It doesn’t shut off completely when we’re awake, and researchers are still investigating exactly how these processes work in humans.

Research on the glymphatic system and sleep helps explain why protecting sleep may be important for long-term brain health.

You can also explore my article about the lymphatic system and its role in well-being. Both are important to overall health.

But What if You’ve Tried “Everything” to Improve Your Sleep?

I get it. It feels like you have no other options. Especially when women are in perimenopause or beyond.

Hot flashes, night sweats, joint pain, and racing thoughts can make a good night’s sleep feel impossible.

These are real physiological challenges. But we shouldn’t assume that because sleep has become difficult, there’s nothing we can do to improve it.

Sometimes we underestimate how much our daily habits influence sleep.

Before concluding that nothing works, consider whether you’re consistently practicing basic sleep hygiene strategies:

Turn off phones, computers, and television at the very least 90 minutes before bed. Two to three hours is even better. This one is super challenging for most people. We are super attached to devices. But if you aren’t willing to do this, you have NOT tried everything!

Try dimming the overhead lights and using ambient lighting helps to not disrupt the circadian rhythms. The opposite is true if you have a sleep disorder, but for most people this is good advice.

Make your bedroom dark with blackout curtains or room-darkening shades. Remember, we are working with circadian rhythms and they are very sensitive to light. Are you having that dreaded 3am wakeup? Light might be a factor!

Keep the room cool, quiet, and comfortable: 69 degrees or less, mattress that suits your needs, and quiet (consider using a noise machine if you have lots of noise in your house like I do…they really work).

If pets disturb your sleep, give them their own sleeping space. This is the hardest for lots of people. They won’t do it. So they say “I’ve tried everything for sleep.” But in reality they’ve tried everything their are willing to do. I know it is comforting to cuddle with your pet, but it might not be as restive as you think.

Maintain consistent sleep and wake times, even on weekends. This one is surprising to people: you can’t “catch up” on sleep on the weekends. In fact, if you don’t keep to the same bed/wake times, you are actually disrupting your circadian rhythms potentially. And that means causing yourself sleep issues. Clearly, you might need to work with a sleep specialist if you cannot get to 6 or 7 hours of sleep a night.

Stop caffeine early in the day (12pm or earlier depending upon your bedtime) and avoid alcohol close to bedtime, since alcohol can disrupt sleep quality. I will go one step further: avoid ALL alcohol if you want healthy sleep. The evidence is irrefutable: even one glass of an adult beverage can disrupt your sleep for up to 3 nights. Fact. I know you don’t want to hear that. But alcohol is horrible for restive sleep.

As you might be getting, people feel like they’ve tried everything, but there might be more to try. I am not judging. I know it’s hard. I’ve made all these changes, including eliminating alcohol. My sleep is amazing. Just amazing. But there are tradeoffs: I miss having a glass or two of something with friends. It’s fun. It’s social. So every once in a while I might have one because it can be stressful to hold back at times. But I am not talking about once a week. I am talking about a few times a year, if that.

Clearly, this is an individual choice. You have to balance the stress it causes you to implement the components of sleep hygiene with the sleep you are getting. It causes me zero stress to turn my phone off three hours before bed. But for you, it might cause a lot. Or, you are looking at it because your adolescent is at a party and you need to keep it on. Got that. Just do your best.

For clear, research-based guidance, explore the National Institutes of Health’s Healthy Sleep Habits.

Of course, sleep hygiene won’t eliminate hot flashes or joint pain. Persistent symptoms deserve medical attention, and chronic insomnia may require additional treatment. Cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia (CBT-I) is an effective, evidence-based approach that goes beyond sleep hygiene.

Dr. Sims also offers practical strategies specifically for women’s sleep.

And if you’re physically exhausted but mentally wide awake, explore my article on why you struggle to turn off your brain at night.

The important message is that sleep isn’t necessarily beyond our influence, even when hormonal changes are making it more difficult.

Why Therapy Is Another Important Piece

Food and sleep are foundational, but they aren’t the entire picture.

Even with excellent nutrition and sleep habits, chronic stress, anxiety, unresolved trauma, and longstanding patterns of emotional reactivity can keep our nervous systems on high alert. Your mental landscape impacts your physical.

Working with a therapist can help you recognize your stress responses and develop practical strategies to regulate them.

Mindfulness, self-compassion, polyvagal massage, trauma therapy, and other therapeutic approaches can improve your ability to respond to challenges without remaining in a constant state of fight-or-flight.

Therapy can also help you examine longstanding beliefs about food, productivity, rest, and self-care. For many women, learning to nourish their bodies adequately and prioritize recovery means challenging decades of messages about eating less, pushing harder, and doing more.

Women have the mistaken belief that their needs don’t matter, they always have to take care of others, and they must put everyone else before them. A therapist can help you explore how to update those beliefs. I know: seems like they are totally true, right? Reach out today. I can help.

As we age, supporting physical and mental health means more than managing calories or exercising harder. It means learning to nourish our bodies, protect our sleep, and develop the capacity to recover from life’s inevitable stressors. With just a little bit of knowledge, you can learn how to optimize your nutrition and exercise for more balance and better health.

Scroll to Top